The Mud Connector
Please check out Shadows of Isildur: Laketown RPI !

TMC Player Reviews: DragonRealms


Review Submitted By: Max
Author Status: Player
Started on DragonRealms: 2003
Submission Date: Apr 19, 2018
TMC Listing: DragonRealms

The following review is the opinion of the review's author [Max] and in no way represents the opinions of this website or its staff.

DragonRealms is the MUD that I first started on and the one I have stuck
with from a young age. I played between 2003-2010 and returned in 2016-2018.
During the first stint of my DR career I played a character named . At some
point he was one of the largest Thieves (not the largest by any stretch,
but up there). I also built the largest “family” in DR at the time with
around a dozen and a half members. We started a number of IC organizations
and my roleplay was a “bad guy” that toed the line of being frankly a bully.
In 2010 I stopped playing for real life reasons.


In 2016 I returned. I didn’t return as my old character, because in
retrospect I felt that I had been a mean to people beyond mere roleplay.
I created a character named Maxwelinski who became one of the largest Bards
in that time frame. By now the game had dwindled in population and most of
the players would spend days at a time AFK scripting. Roleplay still exists,
but only in small groups if you make it so. Eventually we rebuilt a large
family.


During this period I “bonded” another character (DR’s version of marriage)
and we began a relationship out of the game as well over the course of two
years. The player applied to be a GameMaster (GM), the paid volunteer staff
of DragonRealms. Previous to this we both had contact with existing GMs,
two of whom quit and/or were fired.


I learned a great deal about the inner workings of DragonRealms. I was
given GM training materials (despite being a violation of the rules and
the NDA the volunteer staff are required to sign as a condition of
employment) and I was given access to the GM account of the person
I was dating at the time. These are serious breaches of both the
employment contract and of the rules, as well as the spirit of the game.
I was also regularly kept up to date on gossip, passed logs of
cybersex in “private” rooms, and warned of impending “script checks”
that would allow me to avoid the punishment for AFK scripting.
(This in theory would allow you to leave your character running
overnight and progress quickly, but in practice the AFK rule is rarely
enforced so it's unlikely I received much of an advantage from this.)
A few of the largest characters in DragonRealms are privy to this kind
of favoritism.


I learned that almost everything in the game is regularly logged, despite
Simutronics policy stating that it is not typical to watch or log players
for private reasons. I learned that every venue of “private” conversation,
for example private channels, whispers, conversations in the “private”
rooms that adult behavior are allowed in, are regularly watched and
recorded by GameMasters. I became very uncomfortable with this, because
privacy is a concern for me, and I began to avoid all communication in the
game as well as to conflict with my GM girlfriend at the time over this.
We eventually broke up.


Over the course of the next approximate six months, this GM ex-girlfriend
was allowed to put a script on me that recorded my every emote, say, whisper,
and action. I would regularly be harassed out of the game (e.g. Discord)
if I spoke to another girl in game or any friends she did not approve of.
Further, this GM began to copy “alterations,” or unique items players are
rarely allowed to write, and introduce them into the game as common items.
These included personal wedding-themed and relationship-themed alterations
I wrote as well as items based on pictures of my real life clothing – and
even items with references to my name and initials – in them. It became an
intimidating and frightening form of stalking.


I reported this to the senior staff or “boss” of the game, the Product
Manager, who is responsible for hiring. I was told by other GMs that she
would try to bury it, which she did. The stalking and harassment continued
over the course of multiple events (multiple months) until it dwindled but
never completely ceased.


At this point I was informed that the same Product Manager hired an
individual who participated in what could be described as a DR-related
“hate forum” or 'griefer' forum associated with DragonRealms and chats
between 2003 and 2016. (I myself participated on these forums and bullied
players for many years through them, which is one of the reasons I did
not return on my oldest character, although I never engaged in the
racist/homophobic/antisemitic elements of the forum. So I am speaking
from first-hand experience on that side of the fence.) This was someone
who regularly posted racist, antisemitic and homophobic diatribes on
these forums. I reported this, too, to the Product Manager, as well as
the rest of the staff and the corporate owners of the game
(Simutronics/Stillfront).


During this whole period myself and friends were harassed by friends of the
two aforementioned GMs and the Product Manager. The harassment often took on
a sexual nature (sexual harassment) and also involved digging up information
and doxxing players. Despite writing to corporate and Simutronics customer
service multiple times, the harassment continued, the policy stating they
would take no action on events that happened outside of their own servers.
This despite the fact the same group of people have been engaging in the
same behavior in this game for 15+ years.


I received no response from any staff regarding any of the issues I
reported, which I found very inappropriate.


Antisemitism, racism and homophobia are deal breakers for me. When I
learned that this individual was hired as staff I canceled my accounts.
It is one thing to say that you are unwilling to stop the private
behaviors of players out of the game. It is another thing entirely to
hire staff who have regularly participated in stirring up racial hatred
outside of the game over the course of many years.


DragonRealms has many good features, it’s a unique game mechanically in
every way. However, the current Product Manager of the game seems unwilling
to take a hard stance against the abuse or stalking of players, against sexual
harassment by others in the game community, against cheating or rigging events
by staff, and most importantly against antisemitism, racism, homophobia and hate.


I will end on a positive note and say that most of the DR staff is not like
this. There are other GameMasters who are uncomfortable with the situation
as well. However they do not have the authority to do anything and are likely
afraid of the consequences of speaking out as well. If the Product Manager
intends to protect abusive friends they hired it is the final say.


It is a game worth playing for its mechanical features, but only if the current
Product Manager and Simutronics are willing to take a hard stance against the
aforementioned stalking, racism, and so on. No game is worth playing if it
refuses to stand up against hatred or allows its employees to abuse its players.

Submit Comments About this Review